Vote to eliminate the largest and best paid state legislature?

By Dick Miller:

 

WE.CONNECT.DOTS:   The season of voter schmooze is upon us in Harrisburg.  Approval ratings for the state legislature continues to challenge Federal lawmakers for bottom of the barrel.

For the incumbents the strategy remains.  Convince your voters that “I’m doing MY job, It’s those other guys.” and you will get re-elected.

Last year’s fiasco involving an annual budget that never was formally adopted demands additional propaganda.

The master plan is to convince voters that if we can automate enough of our duties, we won’t look as stupid again.

Proposed reforms will always be subjects of discussion coming from our state capital.  Just a suggestion from a lawmaker or two guarantees free and positive publicity.

Reduce the size of the legislature?  How about putting a lid on annual tax hikes?  What about mandating the state’s minimum financing of public education?

Newspapers are filled with examples of such suggestions offered by our local elected legislators.  Most is garbage destined for non-passage from Day One.

Proposals never seem to get out of committee.  A few pass one legislative session but never two, as is required for such constitutional changes.

The budget debacle of last year has all kinds of proposed solutions that diminish chances of history repeating itself.

The most ridiculous comes from the Pennsylvania School Boards Association.  That august body and most of the educational community propose that when an agreement on a fiscal year budget has not been reached by August 15, the State will automatically fund all 500 school districts at last year’s level.

They conveniently forgot the Constitution now requires the legislature to submit and the governor to sign a new budget by June 30, the end of the current fiscal year.  They also conveniently ignore other pressing needs such as social services, hospitals, police protection and the like.

Another suggestion, almost as funny, is that the legislature adopt a two-year budget in place of an annual financing document.  The thought here is that we would have to endure the 2015-16 fiasco less often.  The downside is that lawmakers seeking campaign funds could only shake down or be bribed semi-annually, rather than every year.

There continues to be no shortage of political hypocrisy in Harrisburg.  Mainstream media continues to report these “solutions” as gospel.

All will never get passed in Harrisburg.

Legislators should adhere to required deadlines, negotiate in good faith and arrive at a consensus when legally required.  Mainstream media and local community leaders must start to assert their demands and opinions.

Pronunciations of “we’re nonpolitical” be damned.  Locally we need to be more forceful in our guardianship of public education and important charities and services.

Bottom Line:  Pennsylvania is a non-referendum state.  When you hear or read about the voters somewhere recalling a governor or deciding against issuing bonds to finance a new sports stadium, it didn’t happen in Pennsylvania.

We might put such questions on the ballot here but the results would not be binding.  Our last Constitutional Convention where important changes were presented to the voters was conducted almost a half century ago.

All these suggestions suggest rather than automate, we could abolish our legislature.  Even permission to hold such an event must go through our current legislature first.

Would they vote to eliminate the largest and best paid state legislature in America?  Fat chance.

Share
Updated: May 30, 2016 — 6:01 am

17 Comments

  1. Even if they do, have you looked at the plans? Most shrink the Legislature over the course of 50 years!!! The one with the most support currently would drop 10 Representatives and 2 Senators each in 2022, 2032, 2042, 2052, and 2062!!!

  2. The selected years do make sense. That’s when the districts are redrawn. But yes, I think it should be accelerated.

  3. it should start next year and be finished in 3 years

  4. Pennsylvania does not have recall, which is where the voters can vote to remove an elected official. Referendum is where the voters can create a law directly without the legislature.

  5. Correction: Initiative is where voters can introduce legislation etc. referendum is how it is approved.

  6. Our Legislature needs a Housecleaning and restructuring!

  7. if we fired every Republican we would STILL have too many legislators in Pennsylvania

  8. We’ve got to start getting legislators who are willing to cut the size of the Legislature. We could cut it in half and still have more “representatives” pet capita than any other State.

  9. Go to a single house legislature.

  10. We need to demand term limits for all ‘representatives. Next step, get ALEC and lobbyists out now not later.

  11. IF ANYONE HAS BEEN PAYING ATTENTION, THE PA. LEGISLATURE VOTED TO ALLOW PHEAA TO KEEP THEIR RECORDS CLOSED WHEN PENNA. LEGISLATURE PASSED AN OPEN RECORDS POLICY AND THE AG OF PENNA. HAS NO JURISDICTION OVER STATE AGENCIES INCLUDING PHEAA (http://www.pheaa.org) THIS SMACKS OF CORRUPTION AND MASSIVE ILLEGAL SPENDING BY SOMEONE…… THERE WERE MANY COMPLAINTS FROM PEOPLE ABOUT PHEAA BUT NO ONE COULD DO ANYTHING AS PHEAA’S RECORDS WERE CLOSED AND LAWYERS COULD NOT DO ANYTHING THING AS THEY ADMITTED THAT OUR GOVERNMENT WAS SO CORRUPT THAT THE GOVERNMENT WOULD NOT ALLOW PHEAA TO BE TAKEN TO COURT? FROM HERE IT GETS UGLY…

  12. We have one of the most corrupt state governments in the nation. They refuse to obey their own law and are covering up elder abuse. Stealing from the greatest generation is a reprehensible.

  13. We don’t get to Vote onthe Issues. Like Legal Medical Marijuana. 84% favor it and PA is turning it into a Pill form Business

  14. Reduce the House from 203 to 100 members, and have the lieutenant governor break any ties.

    On the other hand, increase the number of senators from 50 to 67, and every county would have one senator. Tiny Cameron County would have the same representation as Philadelphia County

  15. Should be greatly reduced in few years. 20 now at end of term. 50 at next. All are … just milking the state for all they can.

  16. They don’t need to be a full year paid term; other states have part time

  17. We look almost as bad as NC – pass the damn budget and tax the frackers.

Comments are closed.