Justice Stevens Suggests Solution for ‘Giant Step in the Wrong Direction’

NEW YORK TIMES: …Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. started his controlling opinion with a characteristically crisp and stirring opening sentence: “There is no right more basic in our democracy than the right to participate in electing our political leaders.” …

Mr. McCutcheon was not trying to participate in electing his own leaders, [retired Justice John Paul] Stevens said. “The opinion is all about a case where the issue was electing somebody else’s representatives,” he said.

“The opinion has the merit of being faithful to the notion that money is speech and that out-of-district money has the same First Amendment protection as in-district money,” he said. “I think that’s an incorrect view of the law myself, but I do think there’s a consistency between that opinion and what went before.” … (more)

Share