Posts Tagged ‘julian schnabel’

Review: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly

Posted on January 18th, 2008

Review: The Diving Bell and the Butterfly

We’ve never seen anything quite like “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly,” and that alone makes it worth our attention. Based on the memoir of Dominique Bauby, a French magazine editor who suffered a massive stroke at 43, the movie employs a bold strategy that forces us to see the world from its protagonists agonized and frightening point of view. That condition, described by Bauby’s intrepid doctors as “locked in” syndrome, left Bauby completely paralyzed save for vision and movement in one eye.

The movie begins with a confused awakening; blurry images and sound from a hospital room; doctors, nurses, and their conflicted and conflicting dialogue on the patient’s condition. Then the patient’s gradual realization that while he thinks he’s talking, he’s unable to say a word. For a while every moment is seen from the agonized view of Bauby’s one functioning eye. A sense of dread, that we’re going to spend the film’s entire running time seeing through one eye, is eventually leavened by a rich series of flashbacks.

Bauby was a talented and chauvinistic editor of Elle. In addition to the gorgeous wife and kids he sported a stunning mistress and a coterie of sycophants. Even in the hospital he’s attended by three wispily beautiful therapists, almost as taken with his reputation and power as his former underlings.

Imprisoned in the “diving bell” of his afflicted body, Bauby is forced to endure a procession of well meaning but helpless friends and lovers, more problematic than helpful. His only relief comes from a determined therapist who contrives a tiny escape hatch for the “butterfly” within.

Director Julian Schnabel, working from Bauby’s memoir and an inspired script by Ronald Harwood, has elected to keep the narrators diffident and unsparing “voice” intact. This is most effective in several unnerving confrontations; between aging father, (Max Von Sydow) and stricken son, dutiful wife and fearful mistress, confused friends and colleagues.

Bauby’s painful struggle to re enter the flow of life is punctuated with flights of fancy that will remind some of the Javier Bardem film “The Sea Within,” from a couple years back. Sardonic humor and an undiminished taste for the pleasures of the female body serve as distractions, reinforcing the character’s refusal to give in to his infirmity.

But the chosen form of storytelling is as problematic as it is problem solving. Because the film begins with Bauby already afflicted we don’t get involved in the ebb and flow his prior life. That life is represented in snippets of recollection; vividly shot, but not quite enough to win our complete sympathy. By eschewing traditional narrative Schnabel and Harwood leave a bit of a vacuum. The movie captures your attention more often than your heart.

I mention this deficit mainly by way of comparison with Schnabel’s last film, the stellar “Before Night Falls,” probably the decade’s best film about the inner life of a writer. The fabric of that story; a gay writer/poet growing up in pre-Castro Cuba, was played against such a sprawling canvas, it’s almost impossible to top. Still, “Diving Bell and the Butterfly” aided by several late occuring revelations, builds to a deeply moving conclusion. Highly recommended. In French, true to its source.

By the way, don’t hesitate to seek “Before Night Falls,” from your chosen video library.

More News

Credo

"....I have never made it a consideration whether the subject was popular or unpopular, but whether it was right or wrong; for that which is right will become popular, and that which is wrong, though by mistake it may obtain the cry or fashion of the day, will soon lose the power of delusion, and sink into disesteem." Thomas Paine, Common Sense, on "Financing the War", March 5, 1782

Blog Archives

Categories

Convention Center Series

Convention Center Series Index

Convention Center Series Index

Prologue Chapter One: Genesis Chapter Two: The Dream Team: Penn Square Partners Chapter ...

Convention Center Authority calls for increase in Hotel Room Sales Tax

Kevin R. Molloy, the executive director of the Lancaster County ...

Santa Monica Reporter

HOLIDAY DISAPPOINTMENTS: “Holmes,” “Hugo,” and “Young Adult”

HOLIDAY DISAPPOINTMENTS: “Holmes,” “Hugo,” and “Young Adult”

By Dan Cohen, Santa Monica Reporter "GAMES OF SHADOWS" Any resemblance between ...

Women in jeopardy: three very different thrillers

By Dan Cohen, Santa Monica reporter “The Skin I Live In” When ...

Memoirs

Observations at the top of “Things to do” list

Observations at the top of “Things to do” list

“To be and not to do is not to be ...

Birth rate plummets in Brazil

From the WASHINGTON POST: Fertility rates have dropped in many parts ...

LGH Series

From ‘Soak The Rich’ To ‘Soak The Poor’: Recent Trends In Hospital Pricing

From ‘Soak The Rich’ To ‘Soak The Poor’: Recent Trends In Hospital Pricing

From HEALTH AFFAIRS: FIFTY YEARS AGO the poor and uninsured ...

How Doctors Could Rescue Health Care

By Arnold S. Relman, MD * From THE NEW YORK REVIEW: ...

Penn State/Sandusky

Timeline: Penn State / Sandusky / Corbett

Timeline: Penn State / Sandusky / Corbett

By Bill Keisling Editor's note: Associates of Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett ...