The Kalashnikov machine gun’s real story?

By Slava Tsukerman

Last week a lot of important events happened in Russia.

To name just a few: the rebellious billionaire Khodorkovsky and members of the punk rock band “Pussy Riot” were freed from Russian prisons. And even in the shadow of these events Russian and world media paid great attention to the death of 94 years old Lt. Gen. Mikhail T. Kalashnikov, known as the designer of the machine gun AK-47, probably the most famous weapon of our time. According to New York Times “common estimates put production of this gun at 70 million to 100 million; either number would dwarf the production of any other gun.”

Here is the New York Times article about death of Lt. Gen. Mikhail T. Kalashnikov.

On Friday Kalashnikov was buried with a solemn ceremony as a greatest hero of Russia.

The Russian Government made a decision to give the name of Kalashnikov to the complex of the factories in Izhevsk, where machine guns are being produced.

The story, which we learn from Russian official media and retold by New York Times is challenged by many Internet publications. Here is the alternative version presented by the several researchers.

In 1945 close to the end of the WWII, the most famous German gun designer Hugo Schmeisser has been improving his design of a new machine gun StG44s.

On April 3, 1945, American troops occupied the city of Suhl, where Hugo Schmeisser and his team worked. Hugo Schmeisser was interrogated for weeks by weapon expert teams of the American and British Secret services. They found German designs not fitting to needs of American and British armies. At the end of June 1945, American troops evacuated Suhl.

The Red Army assumed control over the area. Russians immediately started to manufacture weapons for the Soviet Union at the German plant. 10,785 sheets of technical designs were confiscated by the Soviets as part of their research. By August 1945, the Red Army had created 50 StG44s from existing assembly parts. Schmeisser was forced to work for the Red Army and instructed to continue development of new weapons. Stalin was personally informed about specifications of the new machine gun and unlike Americans and British liked it very much.  The guns were very easy to handle. It was ideal weapon for Soviet solders, most of who didn’t get much education.

Schmeisser along with other weapon designers and their families, were relocated to the USSR. On October 24, 1946, the German specialists rode a train to Izhevsk in the southern Ural Mountains, where the center of Russian firearms development was located.


German specialists with their wives in Izhevsk.

Schmeisser is the second from the left.

According to the publications in Russian Internet the famous AK-47 was in fact designed not by Kalashnikov, but by Schmeisser and his German colleagues.  Schmeisser’s work while in Izhevsk (1946-1952) is shrouded in darkness. The most of historical documents of the period are still classified. But some facts are known and they make the version presented by Internet very believable.

AK-47 strongly resembles Schmeisser’s StG44.

Mikhail Kalashnikov admitted in 2009 that Schmeisser “helped” design him the famous AK-47.

But Schmeisser couldn’t “help” him. Schmeisser was working in Izhevsk while Kalashnikov, a senior sergeant lacking special education, was supposedly developing his AK–47 during three years period from 1945 to 1947 in a different plant, in the city of Kovrov.

Several times several committees dismissed his design as unacceptable. Self taught mechanic Kalashnikov was a leader of the local Young Communist Organization and obviously it was pretty difficult to just fire him as professionally incompetent.

Instead he was transferred to Izhevsk in 1947, where Schmeisser and his team worked and almost immediately the AK-47 was completely changed and was released as the perfect machine gun of the future. The name Schmeisser was known at the moment by every Russian schoolboy, as the name of Nazi guns. To use this name for the new Russian weapon was absolutely impossible.

The name of the active young communist Kalashnikov was a perfect substitute.

Besides, if Kalashnikov was the real designer of AK-47, why then in his long career he never invented anything that wasn’t based on AK-47?

In 1952 German weapon specialists were returned home to Germany except for Schmeisser. Schmeisser’s stay in the Soviet Union was extended beyond that of the other specialists by half a year. On his return to Suhl he was closely watched by East German security agents and in several months on September 12, 1953 he died while undergoing lung surgery.

AK-47, being the easiest to operate machine gun in the world, became the most popular weapon among terrorists, revolutionaries and armies of underdeveloped countries.


Russian poster: “Bought a decent thing, became a respectable man”.

Share
Updated: December 30, 2013 — 5:05 pm

9 Comments

  1. Speculative nonsense. Did Schmeisser developed the 1914 Federov as well?

    PS. The AK is not just used by “underdeveloped countries”, it’s also used by US soldiers in their numerous and stupid aggressive wars.

  2. Great article: another lie of the starring actors of the downfall of European civilization (Comminism and predatory Capitalism) unveiled. Thanks for the article.

  3. Apart from the front sight, cured magazine, intermediate cartridge, and gas blow back the two rifles are radically different. Kalashnikov’s and Schmeissers bolt systems are quite different and that’s the heart of the gun. Kalshnikov’s genius was in making his rifle as simple as possible. The Soviets wanted Schemiiser for his expertise in mass production and the use of sheet metal stampings, remember the AK47 was intended to be stamped, but it took longer than expected to master the technology hence the introduction of the milled reciever model 2 for some years.

  4. Right, AK is kind different from STG-44. It means that Schmeisser and other German constructors – slaves developed their design of STG-44 to AK and that’s it.

  5. Speculative nonsense?

    If it “Speculative nonsense” – please answer me – “What did eight high-quality German engineers carry out in Russia for 6 years”. Nothing ?
    But soviet 25-years boy without education but leader of young communists (!!!) designed machine gun slightly similar on STG-44.
    According to picture soviet government fed German engineers not too bad … for what ?

    Let me make guess – soviets fed them for not to continue a work with STG-44. No ?

    Of course they continued to work with STG-44 and received something similar to STG-44 but better one.

    But anyway Kalashnikov out-galloped on “limping goat” these stupid Germans. :

  6. For those who praise Kalashnikov – look what he did before AK-47 – on Wikipedia – looks quite different from AK which is much closer – similar to German gun from 1943/44

  7. La di da, the US wouldn’t have had ballistic missiles or gone to the Moon without German rockets by Von Braun.

  8. Spoils of war with branding and propaganda 🙂
    Everyone is doing it.

  9. Love the deniers. Kalashnakov himself admitted to working with Schmeisser.

Comments are closed.

Newslanc.com © 2016