Posted on January 12th, 2014 in Watchdog


Editorial “The Library Wars” in part comments:

“Maybe the war of words between the library system and the Lancaster Public Library is a power struggle. Or a money struggle. Or a turf war. Or a personality conflict. Or all of the above…

“As usual, this has become a he-said, she-said battle…

“If we had to guess, we’d say that’s at the heart of the library wars: conflicts over who gets to call the shots on funding, who gets the money and what the spending priorities should be…

“More than a truce, the combatants need mediation to get to the bottom of the conflict and to change the way libraries relate to each other.”

WATCHDOG: It is important to avoid ‘moral equivalency’ whereby, in an effort to be evenhanded, diverse points of view are treated as being of equal merit.

In fact, although the majority of the library users visit the three largest of the fourteen county libraries, the largest – downtown Lancaster Public Library with its two rural branches–has only one of the fourteen votes in making decisions for the System, each library regardless of size having one vote. Theoretically the final decisions are made by the System own board but, allied with the smaller libraries’ interests, they act pretty much as a rubber stamp.

Another concern is 98% of the County’s contribution is consumed by the System for its own operations, much of which is redundant, inefficient and, a times, dysfunctional. It has been suggested that the System be made to sell its services and each library have the option of whether to purchase individual services. The System would thus become more responsive and productive. Moreover, County funds would be freed up for aid to the individual libraries.

Meanwhile, while all but about an eighth of State contributions to the System is passed through to the individual libraries, it is by a formula controlled by the majority of smaller libraries and thus disproportionately benefits them.

Hence, the roots of the recent elimination of funding for the popular and heavily used Business Center housed at the downtown library can be traced to disproportionate voting rights.

Mediation isn’t going to solve the problems. Only a reform in voting rights through pressure from the County Commissioners can. It would remain within the power of the Commissioners to allocate some extra money to help sustain smaller libraries.

The only other option is for one or more of the larger libraries to withdraw from the System. In a way this would venture into unexplored legal territories for the distribution of state and county funding. But it may be the only way to end the bickering, bring about fairer approaches, and better serve the public.

NewsLanc long proposed either doing away with the autonomy of the individual libraries or eliminating the System. Based on what has been occurring, we would now advocate reforming or abolishing the System.


Leave a Reply


More News


"....I have never made it a consideration whether the subject was popular or unpopular, but whether it was right or wrong; for that which is right will become popular, and that which is wrong, though by mistake it may obtain the cry or fashion of the day, will soon lose the power of delusion, and sink into disesteem." Thomas Paine, Common Sense, on "Financing the War", March 5, 1782


Blog Archives

NewsLanc looks back at a decade of service

NewsLanc looks back at a decade of service

NewsLanc looks back at a decade of service

At 77, we cannot be confident that there will be ...

Convention Center Series

Convention Center Series Index

Convention Center Series Index

Chapter 1: Beginnings- Revised Chapter 2: Dream Team- Revised Chapter 3: Helping ...

Honoring those who challenged the Convention Center Project

Earlier this month, NewsLanc published “The $63.6 million convention center ...

Keisling on Pennsylvania Politics Index

Index of the ongoing series by Bill Keisling Six Decades of ...

Lancaster Acquisition of Harrisburg Incinerator

Prospects cloudy for Corbett’s Harrisburg bailout

Prospects cloudy for Corbett’s Harrisburg bailout

by Bill Keisling Corbett Administration officials publicly say the Act 47 ...

Coalition forming to challenge Corbett administration’s Harrisburg bailout plans involving LCSWMA incinerator purchase

by Bill Keisling Citizens dissatisfied with the Corbett administration's plan to ...

Tsukerman on Russia

Life in Ukraine’s rebel ‘republics’

Life in Ukraine’s rebel ‘republics’

By Slava Tsukerman In spite of all attempts and of Russian ...

Moscow Air Pollution; pick your poison

By Slava Tsukerman In November one of the most discussed subjects ...


The Secrets of Outlet Shopping

The Secrets of Outlet Shopping

DAILY FINANCE: According to a recent study by Consumer Reports, ...

If you live long enough…

A great fuss was raised by Republicans during the late ...

Santa Monica Reporter

Polar Opposites:  “Birdman” and “Foxchaser”

Polar Opposites: “Birdman” and “Foxchaser”

By: Dan Cohen, our Santa Monica Reporter Two energetic and entertaining ...

Catch these two films before they go!

By Dan Cohen, Santa Monica Reporter Two current films, both of ...

LGH Series

Is LGH / U of P hospital mergers a scam?

Is LGH / U of P hospital mergers a scam?

LNP article headed “Most health system mergers don't meet expectations ...

Hospitals sock it to the poor who have no health care coverage

The following are from a chart and text in “Reinventing ...