How US Health Care stacks up Against Others

Posted on July 22nd, 2010 in LGH Series, News and Commentary

How US Health Care stacks up Against Others

The World Health Organization ranked health care quality by countries.  The USA came in 37th.

The OECD ranked Infant Mortality rates per thousand for 2005:   Sweden – 2.4; Japan – 2.8; Norway – 3.1; France -3.6; Germany – 3.9; Switzerland – 4.2; UK – 5.1; Canada – 5.3; Poland – 6.4; United Sates – 6.8.

The OECD ranked Health Expenditure as a Percentage of Gross Domestic Product 2005:  USA – 15.3; Switzerland – 11.6; France – 11.1; Germany – 10.7; Canada – 9.8; Sweden – 9.1; UK – 8.3; Japan- 8.0

“How many people go bankrupt because of medical ills?  In Britain, zero.  In France, zero.  In Japan, Germany, the Netherlands, Canada, Switzerland: zero.  In the United States, according to  a joint study by Harvard Law School and Harvard Medical School, the annual figure is around 700,000.” *

“Here is a statistic to ponder: Among those nine rich nations, the per-capital rate of ‘Deaths Due to Surgical or Medical Mishaps’ was the highest by far in the USA.”*

“The profit-making health insurance giants in the United States generally spend about 20 percent of all premium income on administrative expenses; the French [rated first in the world] insurance plans routinely keep administrative costs below 5 percent.”*

France spends around $3,200 per person for health insurance which was rated the best in the world.  The USA spent more than $7,000 per capital, did not cover 45 million, and was rated 37th“In the U. S. system, even with its built-in inefficiencies, that saving would meet the basic health care needs of all of the American who are currently uninsured.”

What has gone wrong with health care in the U. S. A?   In large part obvious reforms have been made difficult by special interest groups who are irrationally enriched by our current system.  But since the reforms that are necessary through a capitalistic system as in the case of France are apparent, we must look to the mistaken emotional devotion of a large segment of our population to a broken system.

We need not look further than the public’s blind eye to the causes and the use of the huge profits of our own Lancaster General Hospital to catch a glimpse of the larger national problem.   But how dare we question “mother” LGH in which we are borne, birth our children and form which we seek cure for our ills?

Can we rationally consider not-for-profit insurance companies, such is the case in France and elsewhere,  or government administration (Medicare / Veterans Administration) such as England and Canada that perform the same administrative  functions at a quarter of the administrative costs?

Make no mistake about it:  Health Care costs which are approaching 20% of Gross National Product will turn what was once the foremost economy into a ‘rust belt.’   There simply will be no funds available for investment.   The world our grand children will live in will not offer the opportunities and pride that did the world of our parents.

*“The healing of America” by T.R. Reid, 2009

Share

Leave a Reply

*

More News

Credo

"....I have never made it a consideration whether the subject was popular or unpopular, but whether it was right or wrong; for that which is right will become popular, and that which is wrong, though by mistake it may obtain the cry or fashion of the day, will soon lose the power of delusion, and sink into disesteem." Thomas Paine, Common Sense, on "Financing the War", March 5, 1782

Blog Archives

Categories

Convention Center Series

Convention Center Series Index

Convention Center Series Index

Prologue Chapter One: Genesis Chapter Two: The Dream Team: Penn Square Partners Chapter ...

Convention Center Authority calls for increase in Hotel Room Sales Tax

Kevin R. Molloy, the executive director of the Lancaster County ...

Santa Monica Reporter

HOLIDAY DISAPPOINTMENTS: “Holmes,” “Hugo,” and “Young Adult”

HOLIDAY DISAPPOINTMENTS: “Holmes,” “Hugo,” and “Young Adult”

By Dan Cohen, Santa Monica Reporter "GAMES OF SHADOWS" Any resemblance between ...

Women in jeopardy: three very different thrillers

By Dan Cohen, Santa Monica reporter “The Skin I Live In” When ...

Memoirs

Observations at the top of “Things to do” list

Observations at the top of “Things to do” list

“To be and not to do is not to be ...

Birth rate plummets in Brazil

From the WASHINGTON POST: Fertility rates have dropped in many parts ...

LGH Series

From ‘Soak The Rich’ To ‘Soak The Poor’: Recent Trends In Hospital Pricing

From ‘Soak The Rich’ To ‘Soak The Poor’: Recent Trends In Hospital Pricing

From HEALTH AFFAIRS: FIFTY YEARS AGO the poor and uninsured ...

How Doctors Could Rescue Health Care

By Arnold S. Relman, MD * From THE NEW YORK REVIEW: ...

Penn State/Sandusky

Timeline: Penn State / Sandusky / Corbett

Timeline: Penn State / Sandusky / Corbett

By Bill Keisling Editor's note: Associates of Pennsylvania Governor Tom Corbett ...