Beer distributors don’t want new competitors

Posted on March 9th, 2010 in Letters to the Editor

Beer distributors don’t want new competitors

Food stores aren’t allowed to use milk as a loss-leader. The only one allowed to sell milk to consumers below state minimum prices is a dairy farmer who sells milk on his own farm.

Ohio, like Pennsylvania, has state stores for the sale of liquor, but has several types of licenses for establishments. Some places offering beverage alcohol by the drink can handle only 3.2% beer, others are allowed to sell regular 6.0% beer, malt liquor, and wine as well, and full service establishments are allowed to sell all legal alcoholic beverages by the drink. Some licenses allow carryout sales and others do not. However, minimum prices are enforced on prepackaged beverage alcohol, and if a place has a special on draft beer, that price cannot be advertised off the premises.

It might be reasonable to prohibit sale of gasoline by beverage alcohol retailers, but is there a reason why the sale of bread, milk, and hot dogs should be prohibited? After all, if a business sells both, it’s pretty hard to tell whether it’s an alcohol distributor selling food or a food store selling alcohol.

If selling people beer in supermarkets hurts taverns, that means that people are driving home before drinking, instead of drinking before driving home. That looks like less problem drinking to me.

Does the use of beer distributors make craft beers more available? It’s pretty easy to test that theory. Walk into 5 beer distributors’ stores, and see how many craft beers are available at each. There are a few distributors that carry a wide variety of brands; most can’t be bothered.

There aren’t many butcher shops in Lancaster. It’s not because people have given up eating beef, and it’s not because they’ve bred cattle that have only the most popular cuts of beef. If you want beef shanks, or tripe, all you have to do is ask at most supermarkets, because they are striving to win shoppers by offering products their competitors aren’t offering. Walk through the produce department and count the types of fruits and vegetables offered today that weren’t available in supermarkets 30 years ago.

Undoubtedly, beer distributors don’t want new competitors – but there’s no sound reason why their monopoly interests should be maintained. Allowing people to pick up a six pack or a case when they buy their other groceries cuts down on traffic on the roads, cuts down on gasoline expenses by consumers, and leaves more money in consumers’ pockets.

Share

Leave a Reply

*

More News

Credo

"....I have never made it a consideration whether the subject was popular or unpopular, but whether it was right or wrong; for that which is right will become popular, and that which is wrong, though by mistake it may obtain the cry or fashion of the day, will soon lose the power of delusion, and sink into disesteem." Thomas Paine, Common Sense, on "Financing the War", March 5, 1782

Blog Archives

Categories

Convention Center Series

Convention Center Series Index

Convention Center Series Index

Prologue Chapter One: Genesis Chapter Two: The Dream Team: Penn Square Partners Chapter ...

What the Convention Center CSL Report really said

The "Conventions, Sports & Leisure” (CSL) Report is largely a ...

Keisling on Pennsylvania Politics

Keisling on Pennsylvania Politics Index

Keisling on Pennsylvania Politics Index

Index of the ongoing series by Bill Keisling Harrisburg Watershed Series Part ...

Harrisburg Incinerator Forensic Report deal with last desperate attempt – Part Six of the Watershed Series

A series by Bill Keisling The Harrisburg Authority's forensic audit of ...

Santa Monica Reporter

Santa Monica reporter comments on Academy Awards

Santa Monica reporter comments on Academy Awards

I thought the show was one of the best in ...

Oscar Hangover: Part 2

By Dan Cohen, NewsLanc’s Santa Monica Reporter Last time I talked about ...

Memoirs

Face Blindness: ‘60 Minutes’ Spotlights Rare Condition Of Prosopagnosia

Face Blindness: ‘60 Minutes’ Spotlights Rare Condition Of Prosopagnosia

HUFFINGTON POST: it like not to recognize your best friend's ...

A seventy-fifth birthday wish

By Robert Edwin Field Over dinner earlier in the week, a ...

LGH Series

Sunday News:  “LGH surplus down, but healthy at $63.2 million”

Sunday News: “LGH surplus down, but healthy at $63.2 million”

Lancaster General Health has  published its annual 990 federal financial ...